Tuesday, November 5, 2013

Derogation and Threats to the Life of the Nation

In the Loveless case which we examine this week, which was an early case considering the latitude for states to derogate from rights obligations during times of national emergency, when the life of the nation is threatened, the Court was quite deferential to the state's interests. In thinking about this, you might be interested in looking at how the House of Lords more recently considered the issue of derogation from rights due to threats to the life of the nation, in A(F.C.) v. the Home Secretary [2004].

The case (you can find the full judgment here) involved the "certification" of the applicants under the Anti-Terrorism, Crime and Security Act, 2001, which permitted the government to detain persons so certified for an indefinite period. The government of the U.K. argued that the law constituted a permitted derogation from its obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights.

As part of the decision, Lord Hoffman considered what "the life of the nation" meant in Art. 15 of the Convention, and wrote as follows (continued below the fold):

Friday, November 1, 2013

Latest Turn in Hijab Debate in Turkey

Following on our recent discussion of the Sahin v. Turkey case, you all might be interested by this news story from yesterday, regarding the reaction to three members of parliament wearing hijab in the parliamentary chamber.

Tuesday, October 29, 2013

NSA Spying and International Law

You will all have heard about the growing furor over NSA spying in foreign countries, including on the leaders of a number of countries that are friends and allies of the U.S. Now a number of outraged allies, lead by Germany and Brazil, are moving to propose a U.N. General Assembly Resolution on the issue of restraining such conduct.

What does international law say about this kind of spying? Can we separate that which is permissible, even if perhaps not wise or diplomatic, from that which is actually in violation of international law? How would you go about exploring these questions?

ILSA Quarterly - Rachel's Article on Chile

The ILSA Quarterly was published a week or so ago. Rachel is an editor for the journal, and she has a short article published in this issue, on the topic of a Chilean court's refusal to prosecute a former General for murder committed in his official capacity during the Pinochet regime. You will find Rachel's article on p.8. Congrats on the publication!

Monday, October 28, 2013

Human Rights Committee Observations


Above is an example of a Human Rights Committee observations in response to a state's periodic report, which each state submits pursuant to its obligations under the ICCPR. The Third Periodic Report of the United States of America, to which this document is a response, can be found here.Consider whether such reporting, and resulting response from the Human Rights Committee, is effective as a mechanism for mobilizing compliance with state obligations.

The Power of Compound Interest


Further to our discussion of damages and costs in litigation, and the difference between compound and simple interest, here is a link to a spreadsheet that illustrates the power of compound interest. It includes the formulas you can use to calculate straight-forward compound interest.

Important to note is that an investment of $15,000 in an account earning compound interest, calculated and paid monthly, at a rate of 6% per annum, will earn $31,653.07 more in interest, than an account earning simple interest at the same rate over the same period.

Compound interest is even more powerful when the principal is increasing with each period. So, if you took $2 each week (the amount you might be tempted to spend on lottery tickets), and invested it in an account earning 6% per annum compounded monthly (admittedly impossible to find in the current environment), at the end of 40 years your account (in which you would have only invested $4,160 over the 40 years) would be worth $15,953, or close to four times your investment. Make that $20 instead of $2, and the amounts become more interesting.

You can find a straight compound interest calculator here, and one which includes the addition of monthly contributions to principal  here.

Tuesday, October 22, 2013

Recent Nationality Case

Returning to our consideration of the principles of international law relating to nationality, and the presumption against laws that would lead to statelessness, Amnesty International is calling on the government of the Dominican Republic to reject a constitutional court ruling that would potentially strip citizens of foreign descent of their nationality and leave them stateless.