As we discussed in class, the issue of self-determination is being raised in real time in two countries right now, and in both cases it is leading to significant crisis.
As we talked about, the Kurds have voted for independence, and the Iraqi government is responding with a heavy hand. Here is a legal analysis of the issues there.
After our last class, this Sunday, the Catalonian people voted in a plebiscite in Spain that the government and the Supreme Court had ruled to be illegal, and which law enforcement took efforts to block. The situation descended into chaos as the day wore on, and leaves many experts unsure how things are going to unfold.
Sunday, October 1, 2017
Monday, September 25, 2017
Self-Determination This Week
As we take up the issue of Self-Determination this week, you will be interested to know that real issues relating to self-determination are unfolding on the world stage. First, the Kurdish people of Iraq are voting in a plebiscite today on whether the issue of independence and secession, which the Iraqi Prime Minister has threatened to respond to with force. The U.S. State Department, and the Iranian and Turkish Governments, have both announced their opposition to the movement.
At the same time, the people of the Catalonia region in Spain are planning a referendum there, which the Spanish government has vowed to block.
Do either situations satisfy the conditions necessary for external self-determination and a right to secession and independence? Would either region satisfy the Monte-Video principles for statehood if they did secede? Do you think that either should be granted independence? If one and not the other, on what basis?
At the same time, the people of the Catalonia region in Spain are planning a referendum there, which the Spanish government has vowed to block.
Do either situations satisfy the conditions necessary for external self-determination and a right to secession and independence? Would either region satisfy the Monte-Video principles for statehood if they did secede? Do you think that either should be granted independence? If one and not the other, on what basis?
Monday, September 18, 2017
United Nations General Assembly
The United Nations General Assembly convenes this week, with speeches by heads of state and foreign ministers. The New York Times has a couple of articles on the history and role of the UN, and what people are watching for in this year's session of the General Assembly. There is considerable anticipation of what President Trump will say, both in his speech to the General Assembly, and in the margins. He had a brief meeting on Monday regarding UN reform, which is reported on here.
Sunday, September 10, 2017
International Events This Week
There was no shortage of headlines implicating international law this week, most of them unfortunately bad. From humanitarian disaster in Myanmar, caused by the government violence against the Muslim minority called Rohingya, to a continuing humanitarian disaster in South Sudan due to internal armed conflict; to mounting tension in Spain due to the Catalonian bid for self-determination and independence. One of the worst ongoing humanitarian disasters is in Yemen, caused by both an internal armed conflict within Yemen, and the conflict between factions within Yemen and a coalition lead by Saudia Arabia, and supported by the U.S.
Monday, September 4, 2017
UN Security Council Meets on North Korea
As you all will know, North Korea tested a nuclear weapon over the weekend, claiming it was a thermonuclear device. The US Ambassador to the UN today urged a tough response to North Korea's actions, even as claims emerged that North Korea is preparing for yet further missile launches.
President Trump suggested in a Tweet that the U.S. might terminate all trade with countries that continue to trade with North Korea, which would potentially mean breaking off all trade with China. Meanwhile Secretary of Defense Mattis made a statement in which he said that the U.S. was prepared to launch a "massive military response" in the event that North Korea threatened the U.S. or its allies. Would either of these actions be lawful under international law? Why or why not?
President Trump suggested in a Tweet that the U.S. might terminate all trade with countries that continue to trade with North Korea, which would potentially mean breaking off all trade with China. Meanwhile Secretary of Defense Mattis made a statement in which he said that the U.S. was prepared to launch a "massive military response" in the event that North Korea threatened the U.S. or its allies. Would either of these actions be lawful under international law? Why or why not?
Wednesday, August 30, 2017
As mentioned in class, the recent missile tests by North Korea, and the various proposals for how the United States and its allies should or could respond, raise a whole host of international law issues. Here is a recent article in The New York Times that discusses the facts and various policy options under discussion, and here is a blog post on a leading international law blog that discusses some of the legal issues. Finally, here is another short New York Times article from a few weeks ago that canvasses the question of whether a "pre-emptive" strike by the U.S. would be lawful "self defense."
We will not get to examine "use of force" in detail until the end of the semester, but you can begin thinking about the issues. There will likely be a "lunch and learn" on the topic in the next few weeks. Feel free to raise questions and post comments in the comments section below.
We will not get to examine "use of force" in detail until the end of the semester, but you can begin thinking about the issues. There will likely be a "lunch and learn" on the topic in the next few weeks. Feel free to raise questions and post comments in the comments section below.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




